Don’t Call Me Miss Daisy: In Defense of the American Dream

Most places I go, the way I talk identifies me as a foreigner. Someone who was raised elsewhere.  Every time I have my hair done, I get “You’re not from around here, are you” as soon as I open my mouth.  And just fyi, saying you have a “rat’s nest” in your hair, meaning a particularly stubborn tangle, does not go over equally well everywhere.

People who study dialects and the computer programs they write can usually place me right where I grew up, on the East coast of South Florida.  This particular test also guesses Orlando, Atlanta, and what looks like Albany, NY as possibilities, which I assume reflects migration patterns. But I’ve taken others that can pinpoint the county where I spent my childhood.

That’s pretty specific, but unless you happen to know someone else from that area, and they’d probably need to be anglo, you are unlikely to recognize my speech pattern other than knowing it’s definitely not a southern drawl.  In other words, while I have spent most of my life in the South, people think I talk like a Yankee.

This means waiters try to explain to me what grits are.  Saying, “y’all” does not come naturally to me, nor do the “yes sirs” and “no  ma’am’s”  that are expected in the south.  I’ve tried to pick up some idioms.  People here say “red light” to describe any traffic light.  They ask you “where you stay” as opposed to “where you live.” My personal favorite is “to fall out” which means to collapse.  As in,” Get Miss Daisy some lemonade; she looks like she is about to fall out.”

If that last sentence brought you back to plantation life for just a minute, your Yankee is showing.  The practice of using Miss plus a woman’s first name is alive and kicking (I also hear the male equivalent with Mr., but less often). I am not adjusting well to the deference I don’t feel I deserve. Grown adults, both black and white, who perceive me to be older or of higher status call me Miss Daisy all the time.  I can’t stand it.  I find it terribly uncomfortable, yet it is clearly meant to be respectful.

If it takes me back to being the white lady holding the pitcher of lemonade on a cotton plantation, that’s clearly my problem.  I’m the one living in a foreign culture.  The fact that black women are also addressed this way does not seem to make me feel better.  It bothers me enough, I have started asking people not to call me that.  And if I apologize and tell them where I come from it comes out sounding racist, they are usually sufficiently horrified to remember my preference.

Maybe, like the flag, it is past time for this vestige of southern gentility to bite the dust.  There are many ways for us to show our respect for each other without designating class distinctions in the way we address each other.  Maybe that’s why it bothers me.  I still believe in the American dream that tells us that class is not a foregone state, it is mutable.  You are not trapped.  You are temporarily poor.  Hard work and education can change your lot. Addressing someone by class dismisses the dream.  You are who you were born to be.  And you will forever be addressing your elders and betters in a way that reminds you of this.  Has the South given up on this dream?  Have we all?


4 thoughts on “Don’t Call Me Miss Daisy: In Defense of the American Dream

  1. I have an acquaintance who “misses” me, too. She’s maybe 10 years younger than I am so she’s no spring chicken either. I don’t like it. It feels condescending and I don’t hear her calling anyone else Miss Daisy. I’m also sure she means well by it. Maybe, since I do have a slight drawl, she thinks I’ll like it? Maybe she reveres me. Yeah, that’s probably it.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Imagine how it felt growing up in Mississippi as a child still in elementary school being called “Mr. Don” by adult black yardmen and housemaids.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. You made a ton of fascinating observations here. I’d never heard the expression “to fall out” used that way. The only way I’ve heard it other than its literal meaning is “to argue,” as in the example, “he and his wife had a falling out” but it’s usually used with some form of “to have.” I guess my inner English nerd is showing, but it’s really fascinating how much language and culture varies from state to state within this country. I’ve always liked some parts of southern speech. Maybe I”m a little mean, but I love the pejorative meaning of “bless your heart,” and I think it’s nice that southern people tend to greet everyone with a friendly “good morning,” or something along those lines. But yeah, the “miss” thing is really odd. Your point that you see it less with men is telling too. It’s like they’re treating you with kid gloves because you’re female. It seems to me a bit like a remnant of the culture that said “don’t speak about certain subjects–there’s a lady present!” They probably see it as a respect thing, but for an outsider it creates an uncomfortable, unnecessarily formal situation.


  4. Ref to Nancy’s points: First time I, a Southerner, went to England, my British friends took me to London where we entered various buildings, climbed stairs, etc. I said hello to everyone going up as we came down, and my friends were appalled. I agree — “bless your heart” is delicious.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s